Why Isn't Sam's Club Cracking Down on Resellers?
The recent legal endorsement of purchasing goods for resale in China has led to a remarkable phenomenon within the e-commerce landscape known as "daigou," which translates to "buying on behalf of others." This trend is particularly evident with products from Sam's Club, a popular membership-based retail warehouse. Notably, while platforms like JD.com and Pinduoduo host Sam's products, the items are not directly managed by the official Sam's Club but rather sold by independent daigou agents. This situation raises intriguing questions about consumer behavior and market dynamics, as illustrated by contrasting shopping experiences between urban and rural populations.
In China’s bustling metropolitan cities, young consumers exhibit an increasing frugality, browsing discount deals on platforms like Pinduoduo, known for its penny-pinching approach to e-commerce. Conversely, middle-class individuals in smaller towns indulge in purchasing from daigou agents, often paying premium delivery fees, a phenomenon driven by both a desire for quality and the allure of trying out new products from Sam’s Club. This simultaneous narrative of consumption highlights a dual economy at play on the same soil—one characterized by frugality, while the other embraces an aspirational spending culture fueled by novelty and convenience.
Advertisement
At the heart of this daigou phenomenon is the collision of two distinct consumer psychology trends; affluent customers in smaller cities willing to pay extra for access to products and regular members discontented with their inability to purchase discounted items. The question remains: how does this daigou operation function, and will Sam's Club tackle the issue head-on?
One remarkable case is that of Huang Rong, who has become a well-known daigou in Jiangxi Province. Having worked at the China Post on her campus for six years, she faced immense pressure when her colleagues were required to purchase their own products due to unmet sales targets. It coincided with the launch of Sam's Club in Nanchang, where the steep membership fee of 260 yuan ($40) created a niche market for daigou sellers. Huang discovered that students often sought access to Sam’s through second-hand purchasing groups and clever “entry ticket” arrangements, allowing her to leverage her university connectivity to connect with potential customers.
Initially shocked by the overwhelming success of her first daigou attempt, with over 100 orders collected, Huang quickly recognized the potential in this venture. By forming a WeChat group and promoting the concept amongst students, she not only fulfilled her postal duties, but also began to earn considerable income through a structure of added fees on products—a model that persisted and evolved into a lucrative side business. Now overseeing multiple WeChat groups that cater to various products and services, Huang's business has expanded beyond simple daigou sales to include agricultural products and second-hand items, showcasing the adaptive nature of her entrepreneurial spirit.
Huang is not alone in this market. Local businesses have also started piggybacking on the daigou model, either by offering minimal fees or bypassing them entirely to attract foot traffic to their establishments. The fruit shop owner, for example, mentioned that the purpose of offering free daigou services was not purely financial; rather, it was to segue customers into other purchases, like fresh produce. Such strategies highlight the intricate relationships built within local economies as they leverage the appeal of household name brands like Sam’s Club to drive sales.
As the daigou market flourishes, it creates a tension with ordinary consumers who feel alienated from special promotions. Take Mr. Zhang from Nantong, who attempted to purchase a promotional body lotion only to discover that all stock had been snatched up by daigou agents within hours of release—a frustration echoed by many in various online forums and review platforms. This frustration stems from the belief that ordinary members should have access to the same deals as the daigou clientele, especially given that everyone pays the membership fees.
This sentiment was echoed by taxpayers like Ms. Xie, who witnessed employees at a Sam's Club stocking purchases meant for daigou buyers rather than the regular customer base. Investigate deeply, and one might uncover whispers of cooperation between storefronts and daigou agents, sharing profits while undercutting the very consumers the businesses were meant to serve. It’s a modern twist on commerce marked by an ethical dilemma, where the prevalent perception is that internal employees might be collaborating with daigou sellers to maximize store profits.
Upon visiting a Sam's Club outlet in Shanghai, it was apparent that this tension was palpable. As the clock struck 8 am, a line formed outside with eager daigou agents awaiting the opening. Observations revealed that some staff members assisted these buyers, hinting at an underlying arrangement that may compromise the shopping experience for regular customers. This arrangement allows daigou agents to capitalize on special offers and stockpile items, enabling them to operate distinctly from regular members.
From Sam's perspective, this alliance is tactical; daigou agents introduce high-value orders and potentially widen consumer reach in less saturated markets, essentially bridging the gap for customers in underserved locales. Nevertheless, if these arrangements worsen consumer sentiment and inhibit the experiential aspect of membership for regular customers, lasting implications on continued membership revenue and loyalty could arise.
As the lines between collaborative efforts and consumer fairness blur, discerning the correct course of action becomes crucial. Finding an equilibrium that satisfies both long-term clients and opportunistic daigou agents could enable Sam's Club to thrive in this competitive and transformative market. Through examining the relationship dynamics of various stakeholders involved, it becomes increasingly clear that while the daigou market presents unique opportunities, it simultaneously poses challenges that require careful navigation in pursuit of a sustainable operational strategy. Ultimately, the question remains as to how consumer culture and retail dynamics evolve in response to this ever-changing landscape.
Leave a comment